Former Air Corps officer from Kildare claims he was framed for assault

A FORMER Air Corps Commandant from Kildare is arguing that his conviction for assaulting a lieutenant colonel 19 years ago was a miscarriage of justice, claiming that he was framed by senior officers “who had the knife into him” before his trial.

A FORMER Air Corps Commandant from Kildare is arguing that his conviction for assaulting a lieutenant colonel 19 years ago was a miscarriage of justice, claiming that he was framed by senior officers “who had the knife into him” before his trial.

Nile Donohoe of Watergrange, Kildare, had denied assaulting his commanding officer and using insulting language towards him during an altercation at Casement Aerodrome, Baldonnel on 10 August 2007.

The assault was by way of poking the shirt of Lt Col John Maloney with his finger and calling him “a piece of shit”.

Having been found guilty by a board of Defence Force members, Mr Donohoe was fined 10 days’ pay and sentenced to a reduction to the fourth point of the pay scale for the rank of Commandant by a military judge at McKee Barracks on 12 June 2015.

The Court of Appeal dismissed his attempt to overturn that verdict in March 2017 and leave to appeal to the Supreme Court was refused in March 2020.

He now seeks to adduce evidence of new or newly discovered facts in support of his appeal.

He alleges that following the incident in August 2007, Lt Col Maloney and another officer secretly summoned an army captain to a meeting during which they “pressurised her” to make an improperly founded complaint against Mr Donohoe.

The appellant maintains senior officers framed him and he sought leave to adduce the affidavit of the former captain and a flight sergeant.

At the Court of Appeal on Thursday, counsel for Mr Donohoe, Eanna Mulloy SC said that these newly discovered facts prove an animus between Mr Donohoe and his superiors.

Read full article by Ryan Dunne on the Kildare Nationalist website below.

https://www.kildare-nationalist.ie/news/former-air-corps-officer-from-kildare-claims-he-was-framed-for-assault_arid-20333650.html

*****

Delay – Deny – Die

Defence Forces Tribunal: Collins Barracks army chaplain told rape victim, 17, to ‘forget about it’

An army chaplain told a 17-year-old rape victim to “forget about it” and get on with his life, the Defence Forces Tribunal has heard.

Giving evidence behind a screen, that private — now a married man with a family — said the assault happened in Munster in 1970.

He was one of a group of privates returning back late to a camp where they had been training and a sergeant on duty asked him to step into his office.

But, under direct examination from tribunal counsel Lalita Morgan Pillay, Mr H said all he can remember was walking into a room with a desk and a mattress on the floor.

Then, he woke up as dawn was breaking about five hours later, and found he was half naked and the sergeant was on top of him. He only decided to report it in 1995.

“I had blocked it out for 25 years but my nightmares started in 1995,” he said. “I started getting flashbacks. Things were coming into my head.

“Eventually, I went to my doctor and I told him, and he advised me to go to the guards and he said he would go with me.” Despite the offer, he said he was too afraid to bring the matter to the gardaí.

But a psychiatrist treating him for mental health issues related to the rape urged him to report the matter to the Defence Forces.

“After a few days, I went up to Collins Barracks in around 1995, 1996 and the guards on the gate said they would send someone up to me. They saw my car and told me to wait in his car.

“The door opened and a chaplain got in. I said ‘I was seriously sexually assaulted and I want to make complaint’.

But he just turned to me and said ‘the best thing you can do is forget all about it and get on with your life’. He then got out of the car. He wasn’t in the car (for) a minute. 

Ms Pillar asked what he had hoped would happen, he said: “They should have informed the orderly officer of the day or someone but they took it no further.

Read full article by Neil Michael on the Irish Examiner website below.

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-41936301.html

*****

Delay – Deny – Die

Defence Forces Tribunal: Officer denies putting pressure on soldier to not make formal complaint

The Defence Forces Tribunal has heard a soldier had his status downgraded after he complained about being sexually assaulted by an army chaplain.

Captain Mark Doyle after giving evidence at the Defence Forces Tribunal. Picture: Neil Michael.

A Defence Forces officer has denied pressure was put on a soldier who suffered sexual assault to not make a formal complaint.

Captain Mark Doyle said anybody who makes a complaint to the military police is free to use any number of options open to them, including calling gardaí.

It took four working days to report the matter to gardaí. Capt Doyle, a former senior member of the military police, said legal advice had to be sought on whether the assailant was subject to military law.

“There is no pressure on complainants,” he told the Defence Forces Tribunal.

“We do not deter or pressurise (anybody).”

Sergeant Noel Brennan told the tribunal last week that Capt Doyle had entered a room abruptly, in May 2021, while he was in the course of making a formal statement.

Mr Brennan was sexually assaulted by former army chaplain Fr David Tyndall on January 16, 2015, at Cathal Brugha Barracks in Dublin.

Mr Brennan, who has since left the Defence Forces, reported the assault later out of fear it would impact on his career.

He told the tribunal he “got a bit of a fright” when Capt Doyle walked into the room and asked him if mediation might be an option.

Mr Brennan said he didn’t want to go down that route, and said in his evidence last week that Capt Doyle’s offer was the second time he had been offered mediation.

Read full article by Neil Michael on the Irish Examiner website below.

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-41932626.html

*****

Delay – Deny – Die

Defence Forces Tribunal: Soldier had status downgraded after complaint of sex assault by army chaplain

The Defence Forces Tribunal has heard a soldier had his status downgraded after he complained about being sexually assaulted by an army chaplain.

Fr. Dave Tyndall Photo: Óglaigh na hÉireann/Flickr

Sergeant Noel Brennan, who was sexually assaulted by Fr David Tyndall, also said he felt officers had tried to persuade him to deal with the matter through mediation rather than pursue the formal complaint he lodged in 2021.

The incident happened in 2015 but Sgt Brennan, who was applying to join a particular unit at the time, was worried it might affect his chances of being accepted.

He told the tribunal on Friday that he was also worried about the friendship Fr Tyndall said he had with his superior officers.

The former Defence Forces chaplain was convicted at Dublin District Court in 2021 of sexually assaulting his then colleague on January 16, 2015, at Cathal Brugha Barracks in Dublin.

The 58-year-old, who blamed drinking alcohol for his actions, served as a Defence Forces chaplain from 2008 to 2021 before being removed from the role over the incident.

He received a three-month suspended sentence under Section 2 of the Sex Offenders Act after he pleaded guilty to kissing and touching Sergeant Brennan.

Mr Brennan, who left the Defence Forces in 2024, told the tribunal he had gone to Fr Tyndall’s residence in Cathal Brugha Barracks for help with getting an annulment of his marriage.

Read full article by Neil Michael on the Irish Examiner website below.

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-41931354.html

*****

Delay – Deny – Die

Defence Forces complaints process should be independent of military command, say officers

Much of the Defence Forces complaints process should be “externalised” and run by people outside the chain of military command, according to the Representative Association of Commissioned Officers.

On the second day of the Defence Forces Tribunal, RACO deputy general secretary Colonel Derek Priestley said too few officers are qualified to handle complaints within the Defence Forces.

He also said his members are frequently exasperated when ordered to investigate allegations against soldiers, regardless of their rank. “Most would want to do their best but they would express concerns that they can’t,” he said.

There are also issues around impartiality, Col Priestley said, with officers very often knowing individuals they are ordered to investigate.

In answer to questions from Ms Justice Ann Power, he admitted officers tasked with handling complaints also often just don’t have the time to investigate them — “on top of everything else”.

He said there is also “a lack of training, a lack of manpower and lack of experience” as far as the complaints process is concerned.

Read full article by Neil Michael on the Irish Examiner website below.

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-41930514.html

*****

Delay – Deny – Die

Defence Forces Tribunal: Officer declines to answer whether ‘a good soldier’ would complain

As the Defence Forces Tribunal resumed on Wednesday, a senior officer involved in human resources declined to answer whether “a good soldier” would complain.

The question was asked by senior counsel Gareth Compton, who represents serving and former members of the Defence Forces.

The exchange led to objections from a barrister for the State.

Earlier, Colonel Daragh O’Brien was asked if it had ever occurred to him that the Defence Forces’ complaints process should be run externally.

Mr Compton told him serving and former soldiers had repeatedly testified that they have “no confidence that the current (complaints) process is confidential”.

He asked if the notion of taking the complaints process “outside the chain of command to an external body” had ever occurred to him.

The cavalry officer, who has also served in the Defence Forces transformation management office, replied: “I cannot speak to that. It’s outside my remit.” 

Mr Compton said that such a move would “seem like a natural conclusion”.

Col O’Brien replied: “I cannot comment.”

Mr Compton then asked: “Would a good soldier complain?”

Col O’Brien, whose duty abroad includes tours in Lebanon, Kosovo, Afghanistan, and Mali, remained silent and the barrister sat down after there were objections about his question.

Read full article by Neil Michael on the Irish Examiner website below.

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-41930046.html

*****

Delay – Deny – Die