Defence Forces Tribunal: Collins Barracks army chaplain told rape victim, 17, to ‘forget about it’

An army chaplain told a 17-year-old rape victim to “forget about it” and get on with his life, the Defence Forces Tribunal has heard.

Giving evidence behind a screen, that private — now a married man with a family — said the assault happened in Munster in 1970.

He was one of a group of privates returning back late to a camp where they had been training and a sergeant on duty asked him to step into his office.

But, under direct examination from tribunal counsel Lalita Morgan Pillay, Mr H said all he can remember was walking into a room with a desk and a mattress on the floor.

Then, he woke up as dawn was breaking about five hours later, and found he was half naked and the sergeant was on top of him. He only decided to report it in 1995.

“I had blocked it out for 25 years but my nightmares started in 1995,” he said. “I started getting flashbacks. Things were coming into my head.

“Eventually, I went to my doctor and I told him, and he advised me to go to the guards and he said he would go with me.” Despite the offer, he said he was too afraid to bring the matter to the gardaí.

But a psychiatrist treating him for mental health issues related to the rape urged him to report the matter to the Defence Forces.

“After a few days, I went up to Collins Barracks in around 1995, 1996 and the guards on the gate said they would send someone up to me. They saw my car and told me to wait in his car.

“The door opened and a chaplain got in. I said ‘I was seriously sexually assaulted and I want to make complaint’.

But he just turned to me and said ‘the best thing you can do is forget all about it and get on with your life’. He then got out of the car. He wasn’t in the car (for) a minute. 

Ms Pillar asked what he had hoped would happen, he said: “They should have informed the orderly officer of the day or someone but they took it no further.

Read full article by Neil Michael on the Irish Examiner website below.

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-41936301.html

*****

Delay – Deny – Die

Defence Forces Tribunal: Officer denies putting pressure on soldier to not make formal complaint

The Defence Forces Tribunal has heard a soldier had his status downgraded after he complained about being sexually assaulted by an army chaplain.

Captain Mark Doyle after giving evidence at the Defence Forces Tribunal. Picture: Neil Michael.

A Defence Forces officer has denied pressure was put on a soldier who suffered sexual assault to not make a formal complaint.

Captain Mark Doyle said anybody who makes a complaint to the military police is free to use any number of options open to them, including calling gardaí.

It took four working days to report the matter to gardaí. Capt Doyle, a former senior member of the military police, said legal advice had to be sought on whether the assailant was subject to military law.

“There is no pressure on complainants,” he told the Defence Forces Tribunal.

“We do not deter or pressurise (anybody).”

Sergeant Noel Brennan told the tribunal last week that Capt Doyle had entered a room abruptly, in May 2021, while he was in the course of making a formal statement.

Mr Brennan was sexually assaulted by former army chaplain Fr David Tyndall on January 16, 2015, at Cathal Brugha Barracks in Dublin.

Mr Brennan, who has since left the Defence Forces, reported the assault later out of fear it would impact on his career.

He told the tribunal he “got a bit of a fright” when Capt Doyle walked into the room and asked him if mediation might be an option.

Mr Brennan said he didn’t want to go down that route, and said in his evidence last week that Capt Doyle’s offer was the second time he had been offered mediation.

Read full article by Neil Michael on the Irish Examiner website below.

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-41932626.html

*****

Delay – Deny – Die

Dáil Éireann Written Answers 24/05/17 – Department of Defence – Air Corps – Military Police

Aengus Ó Snodaigh (Dublin South Central, Sinn Fein)

To ask the Taoiseach and Minister for Defence if a military police investigation has been commenced to ascertain under whose orders documentation of Air Corps air quality tests were destroyed; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [24894/17]

Paul Kehoe (Wexford, Fine Gael)

As I indicated to the Deputy in my letter of 17 May 2017, an extensive search was undertaken by the military authorities to locate the two reports complied by Forbairt in 1995 and 1997. The military authorities also consulted with Enterprise Ireland (which superseded Forbairt). However, it has not been possible to locate the reports. I am advised by the military authorities that there are no plans to carry out an investigation into why these reports cannot be located.


Aengus Ó Snodaigh (Dublin South Central, Sinn Fein)

To ask the Taoiseach and Minister for Defence if a military police investigation has commenced to ascertain whether the failure to maintain health and safety standards and the subsequent illnesses caused to staff of the Air Corps breached military law; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [24895/17]

Paul Kehoe (Wexford, Fine Gael)

As I indicated in my responses to other recent Parliamentary Questions on this issue, a small number of former and serving Air Corps personnel are suing the Minister for Defence alleging personal injuries arising from exposure to workplace chemicals. You will appreciate that given that these matters are subject to litigation, I am constrained in relation to commenting.

However, I am advised by the military authorities that there is no military police investigation into this matter. The statutory authority for dealing with health and safety matters in the workplace is the Health and Safety Authority.

The Deputy will be aware that following a number of inspections at the Air Corps premises at Casement Aerodrome, Baldonnel, in 2016, the Health and Safety Authority issued a report of inspection with a number of general improvements and recommendations for follow up. The Air Corps committed to addressing these recommendations as part of an eight phase improvement plan. The military authorities have advised me that six of the eight phases have now been fully completed and a further phase is progressing well and will be completed shortly. The final phase is a continuous ongoing process.

You will also be aware that in September 2016 I appointed an independent third party to review allegations made in a number of protected disclosures relating to health and safety issues in the Air Corps which were received in late 2015 and early 2016. Once a final review is to hand, I will determine any further steps required and ensure that all recommendations, whether arising from the work of the Health and Safety Authority or the ongoing protected disclosure review, will be acted upon to ensure the safety of the men and women of the Air Corps.


Firstly the Health & Safety Authority do not have the remit, staff levels nor funding to investigate legacy Health & Safety issues.

Secondly there appears to be no attempts and no willingness by the military to hold anyone to account in Irish Army Air Corps management for completely ignoring government chemical Health & Safety legislation.

Third the minister has never made any reference, neither in Dáil Éireann nor in replies to parliamentary questions, to any concern held by him for the physical & mental health of former members of the Air Corps nor their partners & children.