Catherine Murphy T.D. (Kildare North) Public Accounts Committee
I have one area I wish to pursue. I do not know if this falls into potential liabilities. I have raised this before with the SCA regarding Casement Aerodrome. I have a list of premature deaths of people of pre-retirement age. Since 2019, we have seen deaths of people aged 56, 51, 63, 55, 27, 55, 55, 62, 63, 55, 51 and 38. I can go back to 1981 in terms of the age profile. Given this is not a gigantic employer, it is a stand-out in terms of premature deaths and certainly raises a significant question mark in this regard for me and for others. The SCA went in and carried out a safety management systems audit in 2010. Have such audits been repeated? Is the SCA dealing with active claims now concerning Casement Aerodrome?
Mr. Ciarán Breen – State Claims Agency
When the Deputy refers to Casement Aerodrome, I presume she is referring to the cases in the workshop. I say this because we have other claims from Casement Aerodrome.
Catherine Murphy T.D. (Kildare North) Public Accounts Committee
Yes
Mr. Ciarán Breen – State Claims Agency
We have roughly about ten cases outstanding relating to the workshop there. These are all cases where proceedings have been issued. Liability is an issue in those cases. When I say it is an issue in these cases, we are currently going through all our investigations. There is some outstanding information that we require in the context of the management of those cases, which is a normal part of the investigation of those cases. I am, therefore, very limited in what I can say to the Deputy about them.
Catherine Murphy T.D. (Kildare North) Public Accounts Committee
Regarding preventative actions, I presume the SCA continues to carry out audits. Has it carried out more audits than the audit carried out in 2010?
Mr. Ciarán Breen – State Claims Agency
I am sure we have. I am sorry I do not have that information for the Deputy today.
Catherine Murphy T.D. (Kildare North) Public Accounts Committee
Mr. Breen might come back to us with it.
Mr. Ciarán Breen – State Claims Agency
Yes
Catherine Murphy T.D. (Kildare North) Public Accounts Committee
Along with those cases where I listed the ages of death regarding particular individuals since 2019, and I appreciate this is across the spectrum but equally this is not a gigantic employer, there are also others living with conditions. There is again a profile here in this regard and a similarity regarding the conditions. I presume this is part of the active cases.
Mr. Ciarán Breen – State Claims Agency
It most certainly is.
Catherine Murphy T.D. (Kildare North) Public Accounts Committee
The SCA reckons there are about ten cases at this stage.
Mr. Ciarán Breen – State Claims Agency
I think it is ten.
Catherine Murphy T.D. (Kildare North) Public Accounts Committee
I understand these are active cases, but when was the first one initiated? Would Mr. Breen at least be able to give us a timeline?
Mr. Ciarán Breen – State Claims Agency
I will have to come back to the committee on this point.
Catherine Murphy T.D. (Kildare North) Public Accounts Committee
Okay. I would appreciate it if Mr. Breen would do that because this is an issue that is on my desk constantly. I know more than a couple of the people involved. This is a stand-out situation and I think some of these things are going to be quite unusual in terms of workplace issues. This was my main point.
*****
Again a representatives of the State Claim Agency attempts to narrow down the Air Corps toxic chemical exposure problems to the a single location that he refers to as “the workshop”.
For the avoidance of doubt below are the locations (old names) at the Irish Air Corps where personnel were exposed to toxic chemicals on a regular basis without any chemical awareness training, without chemical handling training and in most cases without any PPE.
- Air Support Company Signals – Workshops & Battery Shop
- Avionics Squadron – Electrical Shop / Instrument Shop / Systems Shop
- Basic Flight Training Squadron – Hangar & IRANs in Eng Wing.
- Control Tower – Due to proximity to aircraft exhaust gasses
- Cookhouse – Trichloroethylene used weekly to degrease the floors
- Engine Repair Flight – Engine Shop / NDT Shop / Machine Shop
- Engineering Wing Hangar – Carpentry Shop / Spray Paint Shop / Hydraulic Shop / Sheet Metal Shop / Welding Shop
- Fire Crew – Due to proximity to aircraft exhaust gasses
- Gormanston
- No 3 Support (Helicopter) Wing
- Light Strike Squadron
- Main Technical Stores – Built on a former Toxic Dump
- Maritime Squadron
- Parachute Shop
- Photo Section – Affecting Main Block & Signals Workshops
- Refueler Section
- Training Depot
- Transport & Training Squadron
- Transport
- VIP Terminal – Due to proximity to aircraft exhaust gasses
Delay – Deny – Die